4:37pm

Fri January 14, 2011
Shots - Health News Blog

Author Sees Parallel In Giffords Shooting And JFK Assassination

On Friday's Morning Edition, NPR's Alix Spiegel reported on the motives of assassins interviewed for a Secret Service study published in 1999.

A longing for fame turned out to be a more important factor than a particular ideological view, the researchers found. "It was very, very rare for the primary motive to be political, though there were a number of attackers who appeared to clothe their motives with some political rhetoric," one of the researchers told her.

Today's story led author James Reston Jr. to write Spiegel about his own theory, developed during research for a biography of Texas Gov. John Connally, that Connally, rather than President Kennedy, was Lee Harvey Oswald's real focus.

Here's Reston's e-mail, which he gave us permission to reproduce:

I was fascinated by your report on assassinations this morning for a personal reason. In my 1988 biography of John Connally of Texas [The Lone Star: The Life of John Connally] I had three chapters on the Dallas assassination. There I developed a theory, based upon intensive research in the back volumes of the Warren Commission, that Lee Harvey Oswald's principal target was not Kennedy, but Connally.

It would take too much time to lay the theory out in detail here. But essentially, the idea is that Oswald, schleppy little guy that he was, had an intense personal grudge against Connally, because he (Oswald) believed that Connally as Secretary of the Navy (before becoming governor) was complicit in changing his discharge from the Marine Corps from honorable to dishonorable, or at least, not redressing the outrage of that change. Oswald's letters to Connally are deep in the background volumes of the Warren Commission. In those back volumes, Oswald's wife, Marina, testified to the Warren Commission that Connally was her husband's target.

I took your report this morning as confirmation of that theory. Oswald had nothing against Kennedy -- indeed, everything suggests that he and his wife Marina admired the president and the first lady. Like Loughner, Oswald had experienced failure after failure -- he was a wretched little man -- but the one thing he'd accomplished was a successful tour in the Marine Corps, and Connally, his fellow native of Fort Worth, had allowed that accomplishment to be undermined, summarily, with no hearing and no attempt to contact Oswald.

Oswald had tremendous difficulty in finding work in Texas after he returned from Russia because all he had to say for himself was that he'd completed three years in the Marine Corps. Inevitably, prospective employers asked if he had been discharged honorably. He blamed Connally for not fixing his personal injustice, and his anger against Connally, seethed. So his killer's instinct, that deep emotional animus, was directed toward Connally. That the president himself was also going to be in the car presented an opportunity that made his act all the more grandiose and historic. (A theme of your report)

It's always interested me that the Warren Commission ultimately argued that Oswald's motive was grand and epic: to decapitate the U.S. government. But little people, with 9th grade educations, rarely have such cerebral thoughts.The Commission felt, I think, that it had to have a motive that was as grand as the crime itself. If my theory is right, President Kennedy was an accidental victim in Dallas.

Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.